Follow

has anyone who lives in the world of fandom ever argued over whether one of either star trek or star wars is superior to the other? i have seen the notion frequently in mainstream portrayal of audiovisual enthusiasts e.g. nerds/geeks but never in real life. i’ll assume it never happens or either i am lucky enough to have friends like y’all fellow SDFers among whom such a topic would be nonsense.

@nydel Of course not, everyone knows Star Trek is vastly superior, why would we argue? And star trek will always be the best, a pissing match between two production companies won't ever give us a series of increasingly bad non-cannon films and a lackluster non-cannon show on a streaming service nearly nobody subscribes to....

@Capheind it would definitely be weird in my world for someone to say they get more out of star wars. to me that’s a ludicrous idea - but it’s great for that person if that’s what they like so may the force be with ‘em etc obviously :)

@nydel I think all my conversations have been nitpicking on the differences between them, while discussing how no one with a passing acquaintance could possibly compare them as equals (meaning apples and oranges). And most people I know that like one like the other (or hate them, because they are *really* into hard sci-fi).

I think Venn overlap of mainstream and fandom where this argument happens is the devil and angel on JJ Abrams shoulders. ^_^

@maiki i hadn’t considered that the two franchise titles begin with the word “star” ... that’s the whole thing, isn’t it. the general public is so much more dumb than i am ever able to initially presume.

“today on mashable-or-whatever we discuss the citizen kane vs. upright citizens brigade controversy that tv/film students must be immersed in we presume” would have prompted me to ask a very similar question with little-if-any more confusion.

&& we need abram’s member berries.

@nydel it happens in real life. That's all i'll say. haha

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon @ SDF

This is the Federated Mastodon (GNU Social) instance hosted by the SDF Public Access UNIX System since 2010. Please see https://sdf.org for more details about our ORG .. you may wish to also make us your ${HOME}.

Like what we're doing here? Our BitCoin address is: 17GQEeNNHYPmkdgzHmHXiyMaVfgrhPvGBQ

We also accept donations by CC through Paypal - Click on the coin box below: