has anyone who lives in the world of fandom ever argued over whether one of either star trek or star wars is superior to the other? i have seen the notion frequently in mainstream portrayal of audiovisual enthusiasts e.g. nerds/geeks but never in real life. i’ll assume it never happens or either i am lucky enough to have friends like y’all fellow SDFers among whom such a topic would be nonsense.

@nydel Of course not, everyone knows Star Trek is vastly superior, why would we argue? And star trek will always be the best, a pissing match between two production companies won't ever give us a series of increasingly bad non-cannon films and a lackluster non-cannon show on a streaming service nearly nobody subscribes to....

@Capheind it would definitely be weird in my world for someone to say they get more out of star wars. to me that’s a ludicrous idea - but it’s great for that person if that’s what they like so may the force be with ‘em etc obviously :)

@nydel I think all my conversations have been nitpicking on the differences between them, while discussing how no one with a passing acquaintance could possibly compare them as equals (meaning apples and oranges). And most people I know that like one like the other (or hate them, because they are *really* into hard sci-fi).

I think Venn overlap of mainstream and fandom where this argument happens is the devil and angel on JJ Abrams shoulders. ^_^

@maiki i hadn’t considered that the two franchise titles begin with the word “star” ... that’s the whole thing, isn’t it. the general public is so much more dumb than i am ever able to initially presume.

“today on mashable-or-whatever we discuss the citizen kane vs. upright citizens brigade controversy that tv/film students must be immersed in we presume” would have prompted me to ask a very similar question with little-if-any more confusion.

&& we need abram’s member berries.

@nydel it happens in real life. That's all i'll say. haha

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon @ SDF

This is the Federated Mastodon (GNU Social) instance hosted by the SDF Public Access UNIX System since 2010. Please see for more details about our ORG .. you may wish to also make us your ${HOME}.

Like what we're doing here? Our BitCoin address is: 17GQEeNNHYPmkdgzHmHXiyMaVfgrhPvGBQ

We also accept donations by CC through Paypal - Click on the coin box below: