@ekg
I have a dog who together with my family is the love of my life she is absolutely the sweetest thing. When I want her to do something I give her a signal and she has learned that if she follows the task I have signaled her to do she will get a treat and so she does the thing because it's to her benefit. I'm not ruling the dog we are coming to a mutual understanding of benefit for both of us. On the other hand some people treat their dog differently when they give a